The shortage of property myth

It has been a constant refrain of the property market commentary for many years - "there is a shortage of property on the market"; "property shortages driving up prices" etc.

The reality is that compared to 2008 there is a shortage.

In that year there were 163,488 properties listed for sale and sales totalled 56,071 indicating a clearance rate of just 34%. Compare those figures to the latest data showing that in the past 12 months just 130,307 new properties listings were added to the market. Sales over the past 12 months to June 2014 have totalled just 76,637 indicating a clearance rate of 57%. Simply put more of the properties that are listed today are selling than in 2008 and the number of properties listed is down significant;y.

However as with all statistics, every conclusion you draw is influenced by the data set you choose. 2008 as we all know was the start of the Global Financial Crisis and the worst year for NZ property for many generations. Judge anything against those days and the picture will be skewed.

If on the other hand you line up the data for the first 6 months of each of the past 7 years for which data is available, the picture is very different. (Note there is no listings data prior to 2007).

Total property listings for the first 6 months of each of the past 6 years have barely changed. This year, total listings have reached 63,436 properties listed for sale; hardly any change from last year or the prior year, 2010 saw a bit of a rise in listings. So to say we have a shortage of listings is stretching the truth.

The fact is that we now operate in a very stable supply market. Much as real estate agents may wish to see more properties on the market, the fact is levels in 2007 and 2008 are purely historic fact not a target to be achieved.

Even in Auckland where the pressure in the property market is judged to be felt the worst, listings are barely changed comparing this year to last or in fact any of the past 6 years - the Auckland property market is experiencing a steady supply of new listings. So steady that you could be fairly confident that the balance of 2014 will see a further 22,000 properties listed between July and December.

New listings Auckalnd Jan June.png

Clearly the number of new listings alone does not tell the whole story of the property market, especially in regard to pressure of demand on even a stable supply and so to the above stats you need to represent the level of property sales as in the chart below.

Across the country in the first 6 months of this year total sales have reached 36,164 down 11% as compared to the first 6 months of 2013, whereas listings have barely changed. In terms of a clearance rate in these first 6 months of this year the total sales of 36,164 represent, as noted earlier 57% of the new listings. A year ago the figure based on the first half of 2013 was 62% indicating that there is less success in property sales and therefore clearly no shortage.

Focusing on the Auckland market there is no doubt that here the clearance rate of property is far higher. For the first 6 months of this year a total of 15,090 properties have been sold with a total of 21,002 new listings - a clearance rate of 72%. The same time a year ago the clearance rate was 78% indicating the easing in any pressure in this market over past year with that steady supply and slowing sales - therefore no shortage!